Commenting on translations - phase 91
Moderator: crazyankan
- Sergio Nova
- Künstler
- Posts: 2890
- Joined: Fri Jul 06, 2007 3:08 pm
- Location: São Paulo or Valles Marineris
Commenting on translations - phase 91
Comments on phase 91
page 01 - The throne shall not surrender! (be surrendered sounds as a verbosity)
page 05 - …to use it on the ZOTT finals. (period)
[]
page 05 - …biggest obstacles to his plans: Zekka and Alita. (punctuation - colon and period)
page 10 - Long time no see! (is this expression correct?)
page 12 - Sure! Why not? (punctuation - exclamation; question)
page 12 - You sure this is ok, gramps? (missing comma)
page 13 - Are you trying to kill yourself, Zekka? (missing comma)
page 26 - Your spectator risk waiver, please. (missing comma)
page 01 - The throne shall not surrender! (be surrendered sounds as a verbosity)
page 05 - …to use it on the ZOTT finals. (period)
[]
page 05 - …biggest obstacles to his plans: Zekka and Alita. (punctuation - colon and period)
page 10 - Long time no see! (is this expression correct?)
page 12 - Sure! Why not? (punctuation - exclamation; question)
page 12 - You sure this is ok, gramps? (missing comma)
page 13 - Are you trying to kill yourself, Zekka? (missing comma)
page 26 - Your spectator risk waiver, please. (missing comma)
Last edited by Sergio Nova on Mon Nov 02, 2009 9:23 am, edited 1 time in total.
- crazyankan
- Crazy Editor!
- Posts: 1041
- Joined: Sun Nov 27, 2005 7:30 pm
- Location: Tiphares/Sweden
- TargaryenX
- Barjack soldier
- Posts: 180
- Joined: Sat Oct 31, 2009 12:30 am
- Location: Japan
Re: Commenting on translations - phase 91
It should probably be:
Long time, no see!
But other than that it is a colloquial english expression, likely to be used by an unsophisticated elderly man such as Yani.
Long time, no see!
But other than that it is a colloquial english expression, likely to be used by an unsophisticated elderly man such as Yani.
- Sergio Nova
- Künstler
- Posts: 2890
- Joined: Fri Jul 06, 2007 3:08 pm
- Location: São Paulo or Valles Marineris
Re: Commenting on translations - phase 91
It sounds acceptable to me.TargaryenX wrote:It should probably be:
Long time, no see!
But other than that it is a colloquial english expression, likely to be used by an unsophisticated elderly man such as Yani.
- Burning Angel
- GIB
- Posts: 296
- Joined: Sun Aug 24, 2008 4:28 pm
Re: Commenting on translations - phase 91
I think it should be "Long time no see" but both versions are valid.It should probably be:
Long time, no see!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_Time_No_See Look at the phrase.
- crazyankan
- Crazy Editor!
- Posts: 1041
- Joined: Sun Nov 27, 2005 7:30 pm
- Location: Tiphares/Sweden
Re: Commenting on translations - phase 91
Missing a text line in page 22.
also in page 22, shouldn't it be "but in cyberspace, i'm invincible!!" (missing comma)
also in page 22, shouldn't it be "but in cyberspace, i'm invincible!!" (missing comma)

- TargaryenX
- Barjack soldier
- Posts: 180
- Joined: Sat Oct 31, 2009 12:30 am
- Location: Japan
Re: Commenting on translations - phase 91
One other thing I noticed
It has to be the way I wrote it, otherwise the throne becomes the subject of the sentence. As the throne is not the thing that is actually acting in this sentence, I used a passive construction. You're right that it does sound rather awkward though.page 01 - The throne shall not surrender! (be surrendered sounds as a verbosity)
- Sergio Nova
- Künstler
- Posts: 2890
- Joined: Fri Jul 06, 2007 3:08 pm
- Location: São Paulo or Valles Marineris
Re: Commenting on translations - phase 91
In both cases, the throne is the subject of the sentence. The great difference is that we rescue it from passive to active voice (actually, rescuing the throne sounds pretty interesting.TargaryenX wrote:One other thing I noticed
It has to be the way I wrote it, otherwise the throne becomes the subject of the sentence. As the throne is not the thing that is actually acting in this sentence, I used a passive construction. You're right that it does sound rather awkward though.page 01 - The throne shall not surrender! (be surrendered sounds as a verbosity)

It is a connotation referring to someone who detains the power (in this case, Aga Mbadi).
- TargaryenX
- Barjack soldier
- Posts: 180
- Joined: Sat Oct 31, 2009 12:30 am
- Location: Japan
Re: Commenting on translations - phase 91
Ah, so you're equating Mbadi with "the throne". That isn't what the Japanese sentence means. The verb is literally "to be deferred/transferred/relinquished" and it's negated. The only way I can think of to convey the same meaning without resorting to the passive is to introduce a pronoun such as "I" or "He" referring to Mbadi.
"He will not surrender the throne."
"He will not surrender the throne."
- TargaryenX
- Barjack soldier
- Posts: 180
- Joined: Sat Oct 31, 2009 12:30 am
- Location: Japan
Re: Commenting on translations - phase 91
Changes for 91's script
Page 01
Side Text: He will not surrender the throne!! (changed in accordance with Sergio's suggestion)
Page 09
panel 1
Arthur: Excalibur acted as Melchizedek's master key... (Assuming that this is the biblical Melchizedek, King of Salem, then I have misspelled it throughout this chapter)
Page 10-11
panel 3
SFX: mohhhhhhhn
Page 12
panel 1
SFX: BAH
Page 15
panel 4
Arthur: ...possible futures within Melchizedek.
SFX: zuooh
Page 21
panel 2
SFX: GOSUN
Page 22
panel 1
SFX: paaan
panel 2
SFX: gajiji//zzt zzt
Page 24
panel 2
Mbadi: I'll kill you right here and claim the "Fata Morgana"!! (I must have forgotten to put that in when I re-released this. Also, unless it was a simple mistake, maybe we should look into why you're two pages off from the numbering I have, that could be bad.)
panel 3
SFX: SUPAN
Page 25
panel 1
SFX: DOKYA
panel 2
SFX: ZUBAAN
SFX: gyuru//twist
Page 27
panel 2
SFX: sukkiri!//ahhhh ("the refreshment noise", it represents how you feel when you drink a soda on a hot day
)
Page 01
Side Text: He will not surrender the throne!! (changed in accordance with Sergio's suggestion)
Page 09
panel 1
Arthur: Excalibur acted as Melchizedek's master key... (Assuming that this is the biblical Melchizedek, King of Salem, then I have misspelled it throughout this chapter)
Page 10-11
panel 3
SFX: mohhhhhhhn
Page 12
panel 1
SFX: BAH
Page 15
panel 4
Arthur: ...possible futures within Melchizedek.
SFX: zuooh
Page 21
panel 2
SFX: GOSUN
Page 22
panel 1
SFX: paaan
panel 2
SFX: gajiji//zzt zzt
Page 24
panel 2
Mbadi: I'll kill you right here and claim the "Fata Morgana"!! (I must have forgotten to put that in when I re-released this. Also, unless it was a simple mistake, maybe we should look into why you're two pages off from the numbering I have, that could be bad.)
panel 3
SFX: SUPAN
Page 25
panel 1
SFX: DOKYA
panel 2
SFX: ZUBAAN
SFX: gyuru//twist
Page 27
panel 2
SFX: sukkiri!//ahhhh ("the refreshment noise", it represents how you feel when you drink a soda on a hot day

Re: Commenting on translations - phase 91
Txs Targa.
BtW, dont believe everything Sergio says xDD [kidding]
BtW, dont believe everything Sergio says xDD [kidding]
- crazyankan
- Crazy Editor!
- Posts: 1041
- Joined: Sun Nov 27, 2005 7:30 pm
- Location: Tiphares/Sweden
Re: Commenting on translations - phase 91
Dharko: Long time ago that I saw you at the forum.
How are you Spanish baa:lo releases going?
I am sending the files to Sergio now, see he can do a final proofreading =)
How are you Spanish baa:lo releases going?
I am sending the files to Sergio now, see he can do a final proofreading =)

Re: Commenting on translations - phase 91
Hi Crazy, Long time yesss... I´ve been with some "savefile" problems, uploads, re-editions ¬¬...
But only now [after almost 2 months ¬¬] they are ok
and I can begin to work in the new phases.
The edition of the phase is very good, congrats to Fadeddreams for that, and the translation better [Targa rules ¬¬]
amm, now I´m gonna continue to edit the Gunnm Works [yes Sergio, now u.u], I found a better version [spanish] is a little blurred but much better. When I release some "double-pages" I´ll send You the edited files to finish them [IS A LOOOOT OF WORK AND TEXT!! T.T] is my only way to thanx you the perfect translates xD
If you need something, You know I can help, I have a little more time now.
Finally I´m back T.T
Xau.
But only now [after almost 2 months ¬¬] they are ok

The edition of the phase is very good, congrats to Fadeddreams for that, and the translation better [Targa rules ¬¬]

amm, now I´m gonna continue to edit the Gunnm Works [yes Sergio, now u.u], I found a better version [spanish] is a little blurred but much better. When I release some "double-pages" I´ll send You the edited files to finish them [IS A LOOOOT OF WORK AND TEXT!! T.T] is my only way to thanx you the perfect translates xD
If you need something, You know I can help, I have a little more time now.
Finally I´m back T.T
Xau.