EricaFan wrote: Tue Apr 12, 2022 2:15 am
With the "next time we meet I'll kill you" declaration happening right before the sortie of operation maulwurf when did Alita have time to kill Erica?
A simple and boring answer is that Jupi provided Alita with detailed recordings of Gruntal's destruction and identifying Erica among the corpses Alita concludes that since the destruction was caused by her screw-up, she is therefor responsible for Erica's death.
However, aside from being boring, there are a few things about this that feel a bit off:
At the beginning of BAA:LO Nova says that Alita now has the memories that were previously blocked, which can be understood as memories that she suppressed by intent, and it is only after this that she starts remembering about Erica at all.
Even then, the memories that she recalls are only the "good times" when they were training together as kids, at the same time, she keeps on mentioning that she has a deep pain in her heart that she has forgotten, she mentions this even after learning/remembering that she is essentially a mega-mass-murder who is also responsible for Gruntal's destruction and that she no longer posses an organic brain.
This suggests that her memory of killing Erica should be something more profound than just logically concluding that Erica probably died in something that was from a certain point of view might be her responsibility.
Also in the panel depicting her execution there are several atmospheric entry trails and not just one.
And also, if I'm not mistaken, in the original BAA Alita's arrival on Earth was associated with an attack by Mars forces on the orbital elevator.
So my guess(... short fanfic that completely ignores everything that happened in the original BAA and stretches to the extreme what was shown in LO an MC ...) at how things went on is something like this:
After beginning their P.K. training Erica quickly realizes that the majority of Gruntal's forces are just cannon fodder clowns and if she wants to survive and protect Yoko she needs to make it to the top of Gruntal's food chain. Consequentially she pushes herself to the limit and remembering the times that they got separated and the times that Yoko had to act on her own she keeps Yoko as her permanent sparring partner and pushes her to the limit as well.
On the darker side of things, despite Muster's best efforts, Erica is not inherently evil, Yoko's innocence and the belief that everything she does is for the sake of Yoko's happiness and well-being is like a drug that allows Erica to cope with how wretched and rotten her own existence is. Consequentially, behind Yoko's back, Erica does everything she can to crash not only anyone who tries to mistreat or bully Yoko but also any whom she perceives as trying to take Yoko away from her.
As a result Erica and Yoko become a team and start breaking records, quickly advancing through the ranks and becoming the most celebrated up and coming Kunstler Elites.
Like Tzykrow, most people around them assume that Erica is a genius overachiever and that Yoko is nothing more than a useless crybaby that Erica uses as her punching and pet toy.
The only two people who realize the reality of the relationship between Yoko and Erica are Gelgt and Gelda.
Gelgt is entirely happy with the situation, believing that before too long Yoko and Erica would become Gruntal's strongest weapons and that by exploiting Erica's psychological dependence on Yoko and Yoko's mindless following of Erica he would be able to perfectly control them.
Gelda believes that the situation between them is dangerous and unhealthy and keeps warning Gelgt that the sharper the blade the easier it breaks, that the balance between them is far more fragile than it seems and that what he's going to end with is a pair of shattered wrecks.
Gelgt keeps their training as intense as he can and before too long starts sending them on the most dangerous missions that he thinks they can handle.
Gelda while maintaining a training routine to satisfy Gelgt tries to do what she can to make Yoko more independent and Erika more trusting towards the people around her.
Yoko gets closer to Gelda in whom she sees a mother figure, Erica gets closer a provider of the power that she needs to protect Yoko.
Secretly, behind the scenes and in the background, Gelgt is working for the MBV and as the basic necrosoldier treatment nears completion, the MBV starts pressuring Gelgt to covert the entirety of Gruntal into necrosoldiers. Despite being generally an efficiency over emotions type of person he finds the idea distasteful and keeps stalling.
By the time operation Maulwurf is commissioned, as a team Erica and Yoko are among Gruntal elites and the initial plans for the operations involve the two of them being the corner stone of the operation.
Gelda disliking the operation as a whole and stating openly that it is a clear act of terrorism that would greatly stain Gruntal's reputation, is vehemently opposed to involving Erica and Yoke in it at all, let alone making them the center of it, claiming that it would turn them into monsters that Gruntal won't be able to control.
Gelgt believing that this operation is crucial for Gruntal's growth and future starts seeing Gelda as a decisive factor and a bother and decided to kill three birds with one stone by submitting Gelda to the necrosoldier procedure: To take Gelda out of the picture until the operation completes, to appease the MBV by performing the operation on one of Gruntal's top elites, and, to use the Gelda to gauge if the necrosoldier control mechanism really is just a harmless safety switch like the MBV claim it to be and that otherwise the procedure is nothing more or less than a way to bring dead kunstlers back to life, or, if the control mechanism is actually something the MBV intend to use to turn all of Gruntal into mindless obidient zombies.
To "prepare" Gelda for the treatment, Gelgt inflames Erica's paranoid feelings that Gelda is trying to separate her from Yoko and then orders her to sabotage a mission that she, Yoko and Gelda are going to carry together in a manner that would result in Gelda's death.
This little scheme ends up having two consequences that Gelgt failed to expect, a mildly beneficial one, and a completely disastrous one:
The mildly beneficial consequence is that seeing Gelda, a pillar of strength that Yoko believed to be unbreakable and unbeatable, die in front of her eyes, makes Yoko start "waking up" and start seeing rather than merely watching how fragile and cruel the world around her is, which in turn makes her redouble her training.
The completely disastrous one is that believing that Gelda's death was a result of her own weakness, Yoko start being afraid that she is a burden and a bother to the other person on whom she has been leaning all her life - Erika, as a result Yoko starts distancing herself from Erika, in turn, like Gelda predicted from the very start, this sudden rejection starts breaking Erika's psychological equilibrium.
As the preparations for operation Maulwurf progress the teamwork between Erica and Yoko falls apart and Erica starts being more and more erratic and unstable.
Seeing Erika's deteriorating mental state Gelgt decides to take her off the operation and starts looking for someone else to replace her as Yoko's partner.
Humiliated, unwilling to accept the thought of Yoko being able to survive without her and being terrified of losing Yoko forever, Erika confronts Yoko and demands that she should resign from the operation as well.
The two of them start arguing and Erika reveals that she is the one responsible for Gelda's death as well as for everyone keeping their distance from Yoko.
Yoko denounces Erika as an abominable demon and declares that she wished she had blown up in the mine field rather than met her.
Erika flips and beats Yoko half to death, Yoko declares that Erika is nothing more than a wild animal and that after she returns from carrying out operation Maulwurf on her own she is going to put her down.
Erika suffers a complete nervous breakdown and wonders through the halls in fits of hysterical laughter. Gelgt locks her up in detention and goes to talk with Yoko.
Being afraid of completely losing Erika, Gelgt asks Yoko to try and patch things up between them.
Yoko replies that Erika is a weakling just like Gelda was and that they she doesn't need anyone else and can carry out the operation perfectly on her own.
Gelgt realizes that having rejected both Erica and Gelda, Yoko is now probably on the verge of breakdown too, cursing himself for not having headed Gelda's warnings he never-the-less decides that it is now too late to change or delay the operation and that at least in her current state Yoko should indeed be able to carry the operation on her own.
Unfortunately Caerula, an overwhelming enemy factor that Gelgt didn't and couldn't know about happens.
As Triniad isn't around yet, the MBV have a fairly high level of infiltration into Ketheres and thus Gelgt almost immediately discovers about Yoko's failure.
Realizing that the Jupiter Union will most likely disavow and try to destroy Gruntal in order to hide it's own involvement and that the MBV will use that as a pretext to turn all of Gruntal into necrosoldiers, Gelgt decides to take a last ditch gambit to try and salvage the situation by releasing Erika and tasking her with rescuing Yoko and sinking the Orbital Elevator, hoping that the goal of rescuing Yoko would allow Erika to pull herself together and that sinking the O.E. will break or weaken the Orbitary union to the point that the Jupiter Union would see it more beneficial to press it's offensive instead of falling back and trying to play nice.
Initially this works out perfectly, with the promise of using the chaos resultant from the Camlan disaster to carry a lucrative raiding operation on Ketheres, Erika manages to quickly put together a fleet of pirates, mercenaries and other ne'er-do-wells, slip through Orbitary Union forces and arrive just in time to rescue Yoko from her execution.
However, once Yoko is rescued, she and Erika start arguing again and losing focus, Erika messes the timing for the rest of the operation allowing the Orbitary Union to call for reinforcements.
Realizing that there is no longer a chance for victory or escape, Erika shoves Yoko into an escape pod, launches her through the battle debris on a safe atmospheric entry trajectory and rallies the rest of her forces with a false promise of escape in order to distract the Orbitary Union forces and prevent them from noticing Yoko's escape pod descending to earth.
As she falls through the atmosphere, Yoko sees Erika's ship blown to smithereens, during the weeks that follow, as she lies in a pile of junk and her brain starts entering into auto-hibernation mode, Yoko blames herself for Erika's death and now feeling truly and genuinely alone she switches from blaming Erika for her own misery and troubles to blaming herself for all of Erika's misery and troubles, sinking into depression and despair, she starts wishes she never existed in the first place.
Aftermath:
Since the Orbitary Union kept most of the details about the Camlann tragedy secret, what the dwellers on the surface noticed and remembered was the failed direct attack against the space elevator.
By the time the anti Gruntal punitive force was assembled, most of Gruntal's secret data and equipment was removed from their main base in the Night Labyrinth and moves to secondary hidden bases that were never found.
Core personnel were also given evacuation orders, however in order to create a more convincing illusion of Gruntals destruction the MBV ordered the freshly resurrected necro-Gelda to execute them while in transit and return their bodies to the main base.
About a fifth of Gruntal's forces were resurrected as necrosoldiers.
Due to the 13'th Orakel the MBV put great effort into trying to retrieve Erica's and Yoko's corpses from the battle debris in Ketheres, Erika was found, Yoko obviously wasn't.
During Erika's first resurrection as a necrosoldier her memories were left intact, she ended up in an extremely unstable state and was therefor terminated and resurrected again with reducted memories.
During her first short resurrection Erika revealed that Yoko should have safely crash landed on the Earths surface.
Due to tightening security around the orbital elevator and within the Orbitary Unions space, sending a search party to retrieve Yoko was unfeasible and so the MBV concluded that the 13'th Orakel was still in motion and that when the time is right Yoko would resurface on her own...
P.S. :
I like talking to walls .. they listen .. they really do ... and they know .. I know that they know .. but they never tell .. they never ever tell